Powered By Blogger

05 January, 2018


✔︎ "Russland simulierte einen Großangriff auf die NATO”
Zapad simulated a war against NATO

As suspected, the Zapad 2017 military exercise was much larger in scope. Germany’s Bild reports that Russia rehearsed military action against NATO which included the capture of the Baltics, but also rehearsed a major “shock campaign” against Western European NATO nations such as Germany, Netherlands, Poland, Norway, Sweden and Finland.


✔︎ Eesti Vabariigi 100. sünnipäeva portal


✔︎ Estonia's Centennial Week: 
Monday, Feb. 19 - Saturday, Feb. 24


- Graphic: Scanned and color-corrected from a postcard mailed to my grandmother 70 years ago at the Geislingen Displaced Persons camp in Germany. 




_____________

Friday 5. 
January 2018
_____________



- Zapad simulated a war against NATO
(Bild - 19. Dec. 2017)


"BILD recently spoke to two leading analysts from a western intelligence service who revealed that Zapad 2017 was neither an “anti-terror exercise” nor “purely defensive”, but a dry run for a full-scale conventional war against NATO in Europe. According to these sources, the drill rehearsed the capture of the Baltic states (and Belarus) as well as a “shock campaign” against Western European NATO nations such as Germany and the Netherlands, but also against Poland, Norway and the non-aligned states of Sweden and Finland."



- Kindral Terras Saksa väljaandele: Zapadil harjutati ulatuslikku sõda NATO vastu
(Postimees)
"Kindral Riho Terras kinnitas Saksa väljaandele Bild, et Vene-Valgevene sõjaõppustel Zapad harjutati täiemahulist sõjarünnakut NATO Euroopa vägede vastu."


- Russland simulierte einen Großangriff auf die NATO
(Bild)


- Russia rehearsed war against NATO, capture of Baltics during Zapad
(ERR - 20. Dec. 2017)
"This does not mean that you have to occupy the countries and declare 'Peoples' Republics' or something like that, but that you have to occupy the harbors, airports and so on."




- President Kaljulaid could visit Moscow after border treaty is signed
(ERR - 1. January)
"Russian journalists have asked me under what circumstances I would visit Russia. I've said that when the Estonian-Russian border treaty is ratified, then I'll certainly go and say thanks for that," President Kaljulaid said in an interview with daily Eesti Päevaleht in October last year.”



- Itaalia lennusalk hakkab esmakordselt Eesti õhuruumi valvama Ämarist
(Postimees)



- Latvia, a disappearing nation
(Politico-Europe)
“… the country has lost one-fifth of its population.”




_____________

Thursday 4. 
January 2018
_____________



- In Finland, a WWII film epic spurs praise, introspection
(Christian Science Monitor)
"'The Unknown Soldier' has been seen by more than 940,000 Finns. Some of that is due to its cinematic grandeur. But some is also due to the sober look it takes at Finland's bygone war with its powerful neighbor, even as Russia reasserts her military power today.”
—
“I think that it is good and necessary for Finns, especially young Finns, to learn about their history, and the film indeed does that” says Lasse Laaksonen, a noted Finnish military historian."



- Estonian Justice Minister: the state should not buy air time from the pro-Kremlin Pervyi Baltiisky Kanal (PBK)
(Baltic Times)
"The sums for which public institutions have bought air time are not large, but it is a matter of principle.” 



- Hotspot: Estonia
(Geopolitical Magazine - UK)
[The national border between Estonia and Russia has become a central site for smuggling or contraban activity.]



- Russian political theater
by Edward Lucas
(CEPA)
"Russia is having a presidential election this year. Right? Wrong. In fact, the Kremlin is staging a play about an election, rather than a real contest with real voters, real candidates, real competition and real doubt about the outcome."



- Alexey Navalny and the Empty Spectacle of the Russian Election
By Masha Gessen
(The New Yorker)
“… There are candidates, but their names can appear on the ballot only if the Kremlin allows it. There is a campaign, but candidates are allowed to appear on television only if the Kremlin O.K.s it. There are, usually, debates, but Vladimir Putin, who has been in power in Russia for eighteen years and is running for another six-year term, doesn’t deign to take part in them. There are opinion polls, but their results are adjusted to fit the probable result of the vote. And then there is the vote, but its outcome is preordained. In other words, the event scheduled for March 18, 2018, is not an election, but it is called one."



- Training Early for Post-Putin Politics
(New York Times)
"While experts speculate on what kind of successor President Putin might groom or on which group might take over in the unavoidable infighting after he leaves, others see an opening in this “fin de règne.” An entire generation is looking forward to post-Putinism. Its members have not yet been allowed on stage, but they are definitely rehearsing."





_____________

Wednesday 3. 
January 2018
_____________


✔︎ Peastaabi ülem: paari päevaga Eestit okupeerida pole võimalik
(ERR)
"Kuigi Eestilt võidakse ära võtta mingid maatükid, ei ole võimalik tervet riiki okupeerida päevade jooksul, kinnitas Kaitseväe peastaabi ülem, brigaadikindral Martin Herem."

✔︎ Estonia can no longer be taken within just days, says brigadier general
(ERR)
"Though certain areas could be taken from Estonia, a foreign power couldn't occupy all of the country within just days.” - Brig. Gen. Martin Herem, chief of staff of the Estonian Defence Forces."
—
"He went on to say that a build-up of some sort on the other side of the border that may threaten Estonia wouldn't go unnoticed either. Looking at Russia's 2017 Zapad exercise, the Western countries had concentrated on Belarus, Herem said. "While we can see more. And this isn't just about following their actions in secret, but also about keeping an eye on the public channels, like the press and social media."



- A Guide to Finland's 2018 presidential election
(Yle)
"Finland goes to the polls on 28. January to elect a president for a new six-year term. Yle News has profiles of all the candidates and—for the first time ever—an English language 'election compass' to help voters explore their views."
--

- European elections to watch this year
(Politico-Europe)
[Russia, Italy, Hungary, Sweden, Czech, etc.] 




_____________

Tuesday 2. 
January 2018
_____________


- Interview: President Kaljulaid
(ERR - 20. Dec. 2017)
ERR: "It has been suggested that radicals have been activated by another country. There has been a lot of talk about information warfare launched by Russia in recent years. Estonia seems to think it rather does not concern us, or that we can handle it. Communication expert Raul Rebane begs to differ and recently wrote in Postimees that spending public funds on buying air time on an unfriendly country’s networks – for example PBK – should be ceased immediately."
--
Kaljulaid: "I agree. As concerns influencing public opinion, it is clearly in Russia’s interests to spread conviction that Russia is not all that bad. We have no reason to believe Russia is not doing everything in its power to erode European unity. The simplest way to do that is to spark doubt and insecurity in the people. One must have the courage to stand up for oneself when one suspects the other side of manipulating public opinion to serve its interests."

- Moscow's divide and rule strategy
(CEPA 18. Dec. 2017)
"Moscow’s “divide and conquer” strategy around its borders is so pervasive that it would take a long report to chronicle all the cases and methods. However, the Kremlin has targeted at least four current bilateral relationships in the region either to weaken its adversaries or to control its reluctant allies: Poland-Ukraine, Belarus-Ukraine, Hungary-Ukraine, and Armenia-Azerbaijan."






_____________

Monday 1. 
January 2018
_____________


- Vabariigi Presidendi uusaastatervitus Vabaduse väljakul
(President,ee)
"Sellel uusaastaööl võime olla rõõmsad ja natukeseks ehk muretudki oma Eesti käekäigu pärast. Kohe lõpeb Eesti eesistumine Euroopa Liidus. Tundsime vahetult, mida tähendab vastutus rahvusvahelisel areenil, aga tundsime ka partnereite sooja toetust ja diskreetset abi, kui seda vajasime. Eestisse saabus NATO pataljon, tegema seda tööd, mida NATO on, alati edukalt, teinud juba 70 aastat. NATO kaitseb rahu, NATO ei kujuta endast kunagi ohtu, ka mitte riikidele, kes teda ohtlikuna kujutada püüavad."

- Aastavahetuse kontsert Vabaduse väljakul
ERR)

- President Kaljulaid’s New Year's Eve speech
(Baltic Times)
“… On this New Year's Eve, I think we can be of good cheer. For a little while at least, we can set aside our concerns for Estonia's welfare. The Estonian Presidency of the Council of the European Union is about to end. During the last six months, we experienced directly what responsibility in the international arena means, and we also felt the warm support and discrete help of our partners when we needed it. A NATO battalion arrived in Estonia to do the work that NATO has done, always successfully, for 70 years now. NATO safeguards peace; NATO does not pose a threat to anyone, not even to countries who attempt to paint it as a threat. …"

- President Kaljulaid hümni mittemängimisest: olen kurb ja vabandan
(ERR)



- Estonia's Russian citizens can vote in elections in Tallinn, Tartu, Narva
(Baltic Review)






_____________

Russia
“Trust No One"
_____________


- Baker’s Double Dozen of Neglected Russian Stories #113
by Paul Goble
(Window on Eurasia)



- The Secret KGB Manual for Recruiting Spies
(Daily Beast)
“(KGB) veterans still make up an important part of now-Russian President Vladimir Putin’s power base. All were trained in the same dark arts, and these primers in tradecraft are essential to an understanding of the way they think and the way they operate. U.S. intelligence operatives understand this only too well.”
Part 2:
Part 3:

- Putin Says His KGB Career Prepared Him for the Russian Presidency
(Window on Eurasia)
"Putin made this remark in the course of a visit to Vremya program of Moscow’s Channel One television yesterday during which he responded to questions about his life and historical role."



- Putin’s Secret Soldiers in Ukraine and Syria
by Anna Nemtsova
(The Daily Beast)
"While Ukraine’s military has many honored volunteers fighting to defend their border, Russia’s expeditionary forces often are contractors fighting for pay, and dying in silence."



- Russia’s 2018 World Cup Stadiums
(CNN)
"Russia has spent more than $10 billion building stadiums and infrastructure for the 2018 World Cup, which will be the first time football's showpiece tournament has been played in Eastern Europe."

- Russia's National Guard has revealed that it will use video drones to detect unruly fans in crowds at the 2018 FIFA World Cup
(Moscow Times)
--


__________
_____
_




15 December, 2017


✔︎ This is the last newsletter for 2017, but it will return in January. 
Comments, criticisms, and suggestions: estonews@icloud.com
_____________


We begin with two New Yorker magazine articles, published 28 years apart. 'Estonia, the Digital Republic' talks about present-day Estonia. 

The second article, 'Symbols of Sovereignty’, documents the observations of journalist David K. Shipler’s visit to Tallinn in 1989. I found it to be a powerful reminder of how much has changed in a very short amount of time. 


✔︎ 2017: 'Estonia, the Digital Republic'
By Nathan Heller
(The New Yorker - December 2017)
“Its government is virtual, borderless, blockchained, and secure. Has this tiny post-Soviet nation found the way of the future? … ”


✔︎ 1989: 'Symbols of Sovereignty'
by David K. Shipler
(The New Yorker - September 1989)
“Estonia was initially the most adventurous of the Soviet Union’s 15 republics in seizing the opportunity provided by Gorbachev’s expanding permissiveness, in trying for more democracy and private enterprise than Gorbachev envisions …"
https://www.dropbox.com/s/o5bb170faufoxhg/New%20Yorker%201989%20article%20.pdf?dl=0


_____________

Jõulud Tulevad!
_____________

_____________

Friday 15. 
December
_____________



✔︎ Net Neutrality: What are the internet rules in Europe?

(Euronews)
"EU net neutrality standards were put in place by the Body of European Regulators for Electronic Communications (BEREC). According to BEREC’s regulation, ISPs are prohibited from blocking or slowing down internet traffic except when necessary. The exceptions are limited to traffic management to comply with a legal order, ensure network security, or manage congestion."
--
"The law seeks to protect the user’s right to “be free to access and distribute information and content, run applications and use services of their choice” so people can use their favourite apps and services no matter the internet offer they subscribe to."

- BEREC Report: One year of Implementation of the Net Neutrality rules across Europe
(PDF download available)

- Moscow has Now Blocked More than Nine Million Web Pages
(Window on Eurasia)
“… Moscow has officially blocked 250,000 internet sites but that if you add to these the blocked mirror sites and sub-domains of these sites, the actual number of addresses the Russian authorities have blocked is more than nine million."




✔︎ The Estonian National Museum seeks exhibition material on ESTO

(Estonian World)

"The ESTO festival, which was born in exile as the Global Estonian Cultural Days in 1972, will be held in Helsinki, Tallinn and Tartu in 2019. The exhibition the two museums are looking to put together is to mark the occasion of the festival returning home, the Estonian National Museum said in a statement."

--
"The museums are interested in people’s memories, as well as photos, films, advertising materials, programmes, souvenirs, letters and postcards sent to family and friends and any other pertinent material …"



- Vaid 4 protsenti eestlastest usub, et NATO ei tule ohu korral appi
(ERR)
"78 protsenti eestlastest peab NATO-sse kuulumist Eesti suurimaks julgeolekugarantiiks."



- 200,000 eestlase sotsiaalmeedia konto paroolid murti lahti
(ERR | Delfi | CERT)
"Riigi infosüsteemi ameti intsidentide lahendamise osakond (CERT) teavitas ligi 200 000 eestimaalast nende tööandja kaudu sotsiaalmeedia konto paroolide lekkimisest."
—
"Tuntud Eesti inimeste nimekujuga meiliaadresse on tehtud suvalistesse meilikeskkonadesse.”
--
"Kes soovib kontrollida, kas mõni tema sotsiaalmeedia konto parool on lekkinud, saab oma meiliaadressi sisetada klikates CERT-i osutatud aadressile:"



- In Estonia, almost everything can be done online
(PRI)

Ilves at Stanford University: "The biggest shock of being in Silicon Valley, the (U.S.) Mecca of innovation and IT, is that the bureaucracy is stuck at a level that has really not substantially changed since the 1950s. I think that is at the same level as elsewhere in the United States. It's just the contrast is especially strong where, within 10 miles of me are the headquarters of Facebook, Google, Apple, Tesla."

--
"You can do all kinds of things, like play with augmented reality. But if you have to prove that you live where you live or get your child to be registered for school, you have to come in with a paper copy of your electricity bill. The reality of your sort of life dealing with bureaucracy it is not touched by the digital revolution."



- Presidents of Estonia, Latvia to visit Valga, Valka on 10th anniversary of Schengen Area
(Baltic Times)
"Dec. 21 will mark the 10th anniversary of the signing of the Schengen Agreement which guaranteed free movement between Valga and Valka for citizens of both towns. According to the agreement, permanent border control on the border between Estonia and Latvia was removed, and movement between the two towns was simplified."



- Tusk ja Juncker nimetasid Eesti eesistumist suurepäraseks
(ERR)
"Saksa kantsler Angela Merkel tänas reedel Brüsselis Eestit ja peaminister Jüri Ratast eduka eesistumise eest ja tõstis esile rõhuasetuse digitaliseerumisele."



_____________

 ‘PESCO' 
_____________


- The New EU defense pact: Who’s doing what
(Politico-Europe)
"The pact, known as Permanent Structured Cooperation (PESCO), has already been feted at several launches, but it received the official blessing of heads of state and government at their summit in Brussels on Thursday. … PESCO is the successor of a more than 50-year-old vision for European security cooperation."

- Making Sense of PESCO
(International Policy Digest)

- PESCO Factsheet
(EU)

- NATO Secretary General comments on PESCO
(NATO - 13. Nov.)

"One is that we need coherence when it comes to development of capabilities. We must avoid that the same nations have two sets of requirements for what kind of capabilities they should develop.”

--
"Secondly, we need to be sure that forces and capabilities developed under PESCO are also available for NATO.”
--
"And thirdly, we need the fullest possible involvement of non-EU NATO Allies in the consultations and in the process. Because we also have to make sure that they are included as far as possible in these discussions.

- Can PESCO provide a new European identity?
(Deutsche Welle - 13. Nov.)
“… will be the most ambitious tool yet in the EU's security arsenal.”
(but)
"The idea that PESCO is a step towards 'European strategic autonomy' is still highly problematic to some member states and will need to be clarified …"




_____________

Thursday 14. 
December
_____________


- Gotlandi saar saab taas alalise armee rügemendi
(Postimees)

- Baltic island of Gotland gets own army regiment
(Daily Finland)
“In its 2015 defense policy, Sweden's Social Democrat-Green Party government designated Gotland as one of the country's strategic military areas. In September, Sweden held a three-week long military exercise called Aurora 17. It was the country's biggest military exercise in 23 years and the main focus was the defense of Gotland.”



- Estonia: Europe's Little Technological Giant
(Emerging Europe)
"Estonia is in the last month of its EU presidency. Having called itself the ‘digital presidency’ it is not surprising that many of the themes of this past month are digital: progression on the taxation of the digital economy and the free movement of data, approval of an ecommerce VAT package, and an agreement on further steps to develop 5G networks across Europe."



- Estonian e-government system to eliminate administrative hell in Ukraine’s civil service
(Euromaidan Press)
"The system is called X-Road, and it is an Estonian invention. Its chief value lies in that it secures the exchange of data between different electronic state registries in real time. The system has been introduced in this or other aspects in 60 countries across the globe."



- Guide to Finland's 28. January 2018 presidential election
(Yle)



- European Council Blog
(Politico-Europe)
"EU heads of state or government met on 14 December 2017 in Brussels to address defense matters. They are expected to welcome the launch of the permanent structured cooperation (PESCO) and to review progress in other fields, notably on EU-NATO cooperation."

- Tusk võttis Euroopa Komisjoniga vastuollu minnes suure riski
(ERR)

- Jüri Ratas, Prime Minister of Estonia, comments at the European Council Arrival
(European Council TV)

- EU leaders' summit: What's on the agenda?
(Deutsche Welle)
"As European Union leaders meet in Brussels for the last time this year, three major items dominate the agenda: Brexit, defense and migration."



- Get ready for disinfo 2.0
by Edward Lucas
(CEPA)
"But what we have seen so far, fake news sites, the use of stolen, twisted information, swarms of pretend social-media accounts and so forth, is just the start. Next-generation tactics will be far worse. They will involve audio and video that has not just been edited in order to deceive, but outright invented.”
—
"How will the world react to footage of Vladimir Putin confessing that the invasion of Ukraine was a mistake - or issuing an ultimatum to the Baltic states? How will we know whether these images and sounds are real? And if the Kremlin then denies that Putin said anything of the kind, how do we know if the denial is truthful?"



- Travel: A guide to Europe’s most underrated country
(New York Post)



- First quota refugees from Eritrea arrive in Estonia
(Baltic Times)




_____________

Wednesday 13. 
December
_____________


- Riigikogu võttis vastu 2018. aasta riigieelarve
(ERR)
"Tuleva aasta eelarve arvestab 3,3-protsendilise majanduskasvuga ja kavandab eelarve 0,25-protsendilise miinusega. Eelnõu järgi on eelarve kulude ja investeeringute maht 10,58 miljardit eurot ja tulude maht 10,33 miljardit eurot. Kulud kasvavad 2017. aastaga võrreldes 922 miljoni euro võrra ehk 9,5 protsenti, tulud kasvavad 986 miljoni euro võrra ehk 10,6 protsenti."

- Riigikogu adopts 2018 state budget



- Narvas kaalutakse verise taustaga tänavanimede muutmist
(Postimees)
"Narvas on taas päevakorda kerkinud siiani kahe kommunistliku mõrtsuka nime kandva tänava ümbernimetamise küsimus, 15 aastat tagasi oli see teema esimest korda päevakorras."



- NATO kindral: Eesti küberväejuhatus oleks kasulik nii NATO-le kui ka EL-ile
(ERR)



- Koolielu 19. sajandil – polegi nii erinev tänapäevast
(ERR)



- President Kaljulaid peab oma aastalõpukõne Vabaduse väljakul 
(Delfi)
"Kui tavaliselt on Eesti rahvas harjunud, et vabariigi presidendi aastalõpukõne ja uusaastatervitus jõuab nendeni läbi telekanali ja on eelnevalt salvestatud, siis president Kersti Kaljulaid peab seekord oma kõne otse vana-aastaõhtu rahvapeol Tallinnas Vabaduse väljakul."



- Tallinna-Tartu maantee uue neljarealise osa ehitusmaksumus on 38 miljonit
(ERR)
"Ardu–Võõbu vaheline 11 kilomeetri pikkune lõik on üks osa Kose–Mäo neljarajalisest maanteelõigust. Ehitus algab 2018. aasta esimeses kvartalis ning kestab 32 kuud. Uus teelõik on projekteeritud kiirusele 120 kilomeetrit tunnis."



- Arvamus: Kas Eesti on uus Soome?
(Äripäev)



- Poll: Only a fifth of Finns back NATO membership
(Yle)



- European View: The U.S. Alabama Election
(Washington Post)
“… in Europe it was taken as a sign that the United States has not totally lost its moral compass.”




_____________

Tuesday 12. 
December
_____________


✔︎ Neeme Järvi brings quiet authority to Chicago Symphony Orchestra
(Chicago Tribune | Chicago Classical Review)
"To affix "distinguished" before Järvi's name is only proper, given a long career trajectory that has taken him to every major orchestra and made him one of the most prolific classical recording artists ever, with nearly 500 recordings to his credit. At 79, he is currently artistic director of the National Symphony Orchestra in his native Estonia. That his sons Paavo and Kristjan also are successful conductors gives the Jarvi surname dynastic significance."
—

- Neeme Järvi dirigeerib taas kuulsat Chicago sümfooniaorkestrit
(ERR)




- A Way of Resistance: A Brief History of Buddhism in Estonia

(Deep Baltic)
"The first Estonian to be declared a saint was a Buddhist, and the religion also provided a means of resistance for some Estonian intellectuals during the Soviet occupation."



- Ilves receives World Leader in Cybersecurity Award 
(Boston Global Forum)
“… for his nation’s achievements in developing cyber-defense strategies for all nations, and for establishing Estonia’s preeminence as a world leader in cyberspace technology, defense and safe access."



- Eesti kaitsevägi sai Ameerika Ühendriikidelt Javelini rakette
(ERR | Postimees)
--



- 17 Oligarchs Who Are Shaping Eastern Europe
(Ostpol - Germany)



- Jens Stoltenberg jätkab NATO peasekretärina 2020. aasta oktoobrini
(ERR)




_____________

Monday 11. 
December
_____________


- The Real Demographic Challenges in the Baltic Countries aren’t Ethnic
by Paul Goble
(Window on Eurasia)
“… analysts both in Russia and the West are focusing on the real demographic challenges to these countries."
--
  "There are three main kinds: rapidly aging populations as a result of low and declining birth rates and longer live expectancies, the exodus of young and well-educated cohorts to other parts of Europe, and the declining size of the workforce capable of paying the taxes to support the elderly."



- Standard and Poor's (S&P) kinnitas Eesti pikaajalise riigireitingu senisel tasemel AA- stabiilse väljavaatega
(ERR)



- Estonia to continue five school break schedule until 2021
(BNN)



- Survey: Finland one of most discriminatory countries in EU
(Helsinki Times)
"A total of 25,500 randomly selected first- and second-generation immigrants and members of ethnic minorities were interviewed …"



- Iceland is further away from EU membership than ever
(EU Observer)



- Terras: reservistid oskavad ja tahavad oma riiki kaitsja
(Postimees)

- Välkõppusele Okas jätsid tulemata 145 reservväelast
(Postimees | ERR)
—






- No Russia news this week. 

I recommend Paul Goble’s 'Window on Eurasia’ for news from Russia:

__________
_____
_